Atmosphere

Features

Church of the Natural Law Ayahuasca Retreats: An In-Depth Review for Sessions in United States

The Church of the Natural Law operates ayahuasca ceremonies in both Huntington, NY and New Mexico under the leadership of Courtni “StarHeart” Hale, who claims training with traditional Tiwa medicine man Patricio Dominguez. The retreat charges $1,275 for basic programs, with an additional $350 for optional mushroom integration. The organization claims legal protection for church members practicing ayahuasca in religious faith.

🎯 At a Glance

• Locations: The NY location is on a forested property in Huntington, Long Island (45 minutes from NYC), while the NM retreat is held at various adobe venues near historic Truth or Consequences hot springs on the Rio Grande.
• Approach: Small groups of 5-7 people for overnight experiences, combining ayahuasca with Kambo frog medicine, plus yoga, breathwork, and sound healing. The center emphasizes personalized care and tailored paths from full retreats to one-on-one coaching.
• Suitable For: The center targets professionals, mothers, creatives, and changemakers seeking meaningful transformation. According to reviews, the approach may not suit everyone, particularly those uncomfortable with strong female leadership or expecting individualized attention.
• Costs: Weekend retreats cost $1,275, with optional mushroom integration for an additional $350. Extended programs with overnight accommodations and microdosing supplies reach $1,625 total.
• Overall Assessment: Directory evaluation: C- (notable for modern integration approach, flagged for mixed reviews, authenticity concerns, and negative participant reports).

💬 What Guests Are Saying

Participant reviews present a sharply divided picture. Long-term participants praise transformative experiences, with one attendee since 2019 describing profound trauma healing and personal growth through Courtni’s guidance. Others appreciate the small-group setting, calling the NY location a sanctuary filled with inspiring art and describing the facilitator as knowledgeable and caring. However, concerning negative reviews describe the operation as potentially fraudulent. One detailed complaint alleges passive-aggressive behavior, enforced silence, weak ayahuasca with minimal effects, and abandonment during ceremony when the facilitator retreated to her room. This reviewer questioned the authenticity of the kambo and medicine preparation, describing a bizarre ceremony experience with dollar-store props and lukewarm chocolate passed off as cacao ceremony.

We encourage sharing your perspective through our submission form to maintain current insights.

🚩 Incident Report

Following a thorough review of online sources including Reddit subreddits like r/Ayahuasca, r/Psychonaut, and r/WellnessHive, Quora threads, Facebook groups such as Psychedelic Healing and Ayahuasca Experiences, news outlets, retreat discussion boards, ICEERS safety reports, and public records, mixed findings emerged regarding safety concerns.

• Theft: No theft incidents found in reviewed sources.
• Sexual Misconduct: No sexual misconduct allegations found in reviewed sources.
• Crime: No criminal charges found, though serious authenticity concerns were raised in participant reviews questioning the legitimacy of the operation as a legitimate church versus commercial venture.

Multiple reviews on SafeCeremonies.com specifically challenge the authenticity of the operation, with one reviewer stating ‘You are not Native, you are not part of a Church. You are a con artist’. A detailed negative review describes the retreat as a ‘total scam’ with a condescending facilitator who would ‘pick apart and analyze peoples intentions and prayers’.

New update as of March 2026: No recent safety incidents documented, though authenticity concerns remain unresolved.

🔍 Critical Notes

The retreat demonstrates modern integration with traditional elements, offering both in-person ceremonies and online support systems. The facilitator claims lineage from traditional Inga and Tiwa shamans and emphasizes culturally respectful practices. Courtni StarHeart brings over 20 years of claimed experience and has developed a Four Keys System for trauma release. However, significant red flags emerge around authenticity and participant satisfaction. Multiple reviews question whether this is a legitimate church or traditional practice, with accusations of self-reviewing and fraudulent operations. The legal framework claiming church protection appears questionable, as authentic religious exemptions for ayahuasca are extraordinarily narrow and rarely approved by the DEA. Most US ayahuasca operations exist in legal grey zones with participants facing potential federal prosecution.

🆘 Screening & Mental Health Risks

The retreat’s medical screening process is not clearly documented on their website or in available reviews. While the organization emphasizes personalized care and safe containers for change, specific mental health protocols, contraindications, or medical supervision details are not publicly available. One negative review noted that kambo administration appeared unusually mild with no participants purging, raising questions about proper preparation and dosing. Given the lack of transparent medical protocols and mixed participant experiences, potential participants should consult healthcare providers and thoroughly investigate the center’s safety measures before attending.

🧪 Brew Substance

According to one participant review, the facilitator claims to have a ‘special recipe that prevents purging,’ though this participant reported minimal to no effects from multiple servings. The center does not provide detailed information about their ayahuasca preparation, source, or composition on their website. The organization works with both ayahuasca and kambo frog medicine, along with other substances including ketamine and microdosing programs. One concerning review described unusually large kambo burn marks and a cacao ceremony that consisted of ‘lukewarm hot chocolate’ with ‘no ceremony involved’. The lack of transparency about medicine preparation and conflicting participant reports raise questions about the authenticity and quality of substances used.

📍 Location, Setting & Style

• United States: The New Mexico location is situated in the high desert culture of the Anasazi, described as a legendary hideout of Geronimo, offering historic hot springs on the Rio Grande and red earth mesas.
• Setting: The NY venue features many acres of wooded hills and magical forests with wide open skies, fireplace, and a welcoming house with tall trees and peaceful breeze sounds. All venues include indoor and outdoor space, fireplace and candles, starry sky views, kitchen and bathroom, shared rooms, patio space, and sacred ceremonial atmosphere.
• Style: A typical schedule includes morning coffee and breakfast, yoga and breathwork, sound bath, lunch, free time, medicine walks, gathering and training, cacao ceremony, shamanic drumming, and ayahuasca ceremony, followed by talking stick integration circles.

Practical guidance: The NY location in Huntington is 45 minutes from NYC via LIRR from Penn Station. Contact info@churchofthenaturallaw.org or text (505) 600-9380, with office hours 11am-5pm Monday-Wednesday, and registration via PayPal.

Should You Book?

This retreat may appeal to those seeking a modern, domestically-located ayahuasca experience with integration support, particularly professionals comfortable with non-traditional approaches. However, significant concerns about authenticity, legal status, and inconsistent participant experiences make this a high-risk choice. The conflicting reviews, questions about legitimacy, and lack of transparency around medical protocols and medicine preparation suggest proceeding with extreme caution. Those seeking authentic traditional ceremony or clear legal protections should consider established centers with documented lineages and transparent safety protocols.

The Team & Story

Courtni “StarHeart” Hale founded the Church after claimed seven-year residency with Traditional Native Medicine teacher Tata Patricio Dominguez of DMT: Spirit Molecule fame, and claims certification by the Church of the Spiritual Path in 2008. She holds dual bachelor’s degrees from American University and pursued doctoral studies at University of Delaware before transitioning to shamanic practice. Courtni has authored three books: Finding the Force, 4 Steps Into the Vortex, and Urban Shaman: Love. She has been featured in Entrepreneurs Herald and NY Weekly Magazine as a voice on ayahuasca ceremony ethics and safety.

Prep & Integration Tips

The retreat includes online video training packages, intake calls, zoom sessions, and integration support as part of their toolkit for success. Their Four Keys System includes goal assessment, physical habits like breathwork and nutrition, releasing limitations, and creating personalized long-term success plans. Optional microdosing supplies for continued neural growth and one-month support are available for additional fees.

Pros & Cons

Book Your Ceremony

Booking requires contacting info@churchofthenaturallaw.org or texting (505) 600-9380, with payment via PayPal. Packages include lodging, meals, training materials, and ceremony access with all venue amenities.